English Muffin Pizzas English Muffin Pizzas Print Recipe Pin Recipe Ingredients English Muffins slicedTomato SauceChoice of Cheese -Mozzarella American or ProvoloneGarlic PowderItalian SeasoningChoice of Toppings Instructions Toast the English muffin prior to making the pizza.Add the tomato sauce.Add your choice of cheese.Add the spices.Top the muffin with your meat or vegetable.Place in the toaster oven and broil for 4-5 minutes. Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!